Our Customers Tell Their Stories!

You don’t have to take our word for it when we say that Muth & Company Roofing is one of the most sought-after and trusted roofing companies in Columbus, Ohio.

Carol's Story
Barbara's Story
Millie's Story

From dated leaking roofs to storm damage and beyond, Muth has you covered. Read what our customers are saying about their experience with us!

I’d like to extend my thanks to you and all of the crew at Muth. Thanks to Grant, Carl, Anthony and the whole production team for sticking with us through what, at times has been an anxiety-laden ride.

LeeAnn and I really do appreciate that — at every turn — you’ve treated us fairly and heard our concerns, and made every attempt to get us to a good outcome, and at a price that we could bear.

We’ve kept an eye on the ceilings back there through some pretty intense peltings over the past week and things appear to be bone-dry. We’re going to enjoy some worry-free sleep through summer storms this year!

The Glass Family

After 2 roof leaks and countless discussions with our insurance company, I decided to speak with Tom Nann who works at Muth Roofing. We scheduled a day for Tom and Kelly Wengerd to do a physical inspection of the roof. After completing the roof inspection, both Tom and Kelly met with members of our church council to go over what was found. They showed us pictures and explained what was wrong, how it happened, and how they would fix it. We were informed our 11 year old roof had been installed against code and had several soft spots. After some discussion, it was decided to go ahead with Muth replacing our roof.

During the removal Kelly, and the crew took over a hundred pictures showing how bad the condition of the roof was and how poorly it was installed. Tom told me that Muth does this to help you see every step of the job to document what we are finding wrong to inform you what we are fixing. The whole company was amazing both during the installation process and afterwards as well.

I haven't found another company that is willing to let a let a shingle company do a surprise inspection on their work, and the warranty they offer on the products and workmanship is unmatched. Muth is the only company I would recommend for anyone needing any kind of roof work.

Richard Kapff, Trustee Chairman Church of the Good Shepherd U.M.C.

We were very pleased with the roofers that completed our new roof. It was well crafted. Tony returned the day after and made the extra effort to complete the metal running along the siding which beautified the job.

Thank you Kelly for explaining the job thoroughly and the level of expertise Muth Roofing would provide. That was a true statement.

Thank you Allison for your excellent customer service over the phone. It helped us have a positive experience throughout.
We can see why you are a successful team.

Gregg Wills

All I can say is thank you Muth Roofing! I had shingles blow off in December and had extensive wind damage. Jeremy was extremely professional, and worked tirelessly with my insurance company and the shingle company regarding my claim! He also took great care (and great patience) to explain the whole process to me, which included replacing the entire roof with a higher quality shingle, improving all ventilation by installing a ridge vent, properly venting a bathroom fan and adding ice guard and deck protector, as well as reflashing my chimney and replacing a couple of areas of wood deck. Jeremy was involved from start to finish, always promptly answered or returned my calls and patiently answered my questions and worried concerns. The crew was terrific, professional and cleaned everything up well.

When Jeremy came over to go over the contract with me before work started, I had a male friend/handyman sit in on the conversation since I know little about roofs. When Jeremy was done going over everything, my friend said, "If you had told me it was Muth, I could have skipped coming over here. They'll do a great job for you!" Jeremy even urged me to go with another roof color other than the black roof I've had forever; I did and I LOVE it! Thank you all again for everything!


During the storm on Memorial Day weekend a tree fell through our roof. A neighbor said Muth had solved her roofing problems after 3 other companies failed.

We called Muth and Kelly came out, diagnosed the problem along with other issues, such as insulation and trusses. He was very thorough, attentive and responsive.

We had many other issues to contend with and Kelly and Lisa helped us the entire way. The work crew were exceptional. They worked hard to complete the work on 2 dry days during the rainy June. We would highly recommend them.

They are a pleasure to work with!

Bill and Mary Talbert

We recently had the roof on our two-story home replaced by Muth & Company Roofing, Inc. The Muth representative, Tom N., spent a lot of time with us explaining the roofing and ventilation system. He showed us samples of everything and answered questions until we had a complete understanding of what was involved.

Other companies we talked to seemed to be more interested in giving us a good price. Muth seemed more interested in what needed to be done to have the job done right. They went up into our attic space several times to make sure of what needed to be done to vent the attic properly. The other companies never even looked in the attic. The finished roof looks beautiful and the work of removing the old roofing shingles and putting on the new roof only took two days.

We are very satisfied with it. Our only complaint is that the workers were not as careful as we had hoped they would be of the landscaping. But, most everything survived and Muth reimbursed us for the replacement of one bush that was damaged. One of our window screens was also torn by falling shingles and Muth replaced that as well. We would highly recommend Muth & Company to anyone interested in roofing or roofing repairs.

Mary Maynard

Muth had to work around difficult weather conditions to replace our roof and gutters. Tony, our site supervisor, promptly addressed all issues. All concerns were quickly addressed and corrected. The personnel were knowledgeable and efficient. They protected our property and cleaned up all debris upon completion.

Steve and Linda Hall

This company replaced my 50 year old roof. They were professional and punctual. When the job was done - the owner came out and doubled checked everything to make sure I was happy with the results. They do a great job!

Sharon Jordan

The team came out in a timely manner. He gave us plenty a heads up on the telephone. The team was neat and clean and polite. They did a great job making the repair. They cleaned up their mess and they left. Reasonable price too!


I was very impressed with the response time, courteousness of the staff, both on the phone and those that came to my house. I am 100% happy with the quality of work and would use this company again.

Thanks to Kelly who did an outstanding job, and because of his superb customer service I will recommend Muth Roofing to everyone.


My experience with Chad Muth and the Muth crews could not have been better. Even though we had to replace most of the wood on the roof(the house is 75 years old) the job was done in 3 days! The roof has a lifetime warranty and it looks fantastic.

These people go above and beyond for you. I can’t say enough good things about them. If you need a roof I highly suggest you call Chad Muth.


Want to keep reading our reviews?

Our BBB Reviews

Scroll to Top